Filtration Equipment

Leaf Filter vs Filter Press: How to Choose

Leaf filter vs filter press: why published press solids thresholds run from just over 1 to 30 percent and beyond, and the four questions to ask.

An engineer holds a jar of clear filtrate up to the light beside a closed leaf filter, with discharged filter cake in a tray on the floor.

The short answer

Choose by which stream you are selling. Kanadevia's own selection guide starts with the same question: is your product the liquid or the solid? A leaf filter is built to protect the liquid: a closed pressure vessel that clarifies a low-solids feed and hands you clear filtrate. A filter press is built to work the cake: open plates that squeeze a high-solids slurry into a dry, drip-free cake. If the filtrate is your product and the solids are low, start with a horizontal leaf filter or a vertical leaf filter. If the cake is your product, or its dryness drives your disposal cost, start with a press. We build both, so we gain nothing from steering you either way.

Many guides answer with a solids percentage instead. The trouble is that the published entry points for a filter press run from just over 1 percent to 30 percent and beyond, depending on whose guide you read. The rest of this article explains why the figures disagree and what to check instead.

Two machines, one principle

Both machines are pressure filters. Liquid is pushed through a filter medium, solids build up on it as a cake, and the cake is removed at the end of a cycle. Both run in batches.

  • Leaf filter. Flat filter leaves stand inside a closed pressure vessel, either horizontal or vertical. Micronics describes 10 to 60 leaves "stacked inside a vertical or horizontal pressure vessel", each, in its description, a drainage element under a wire or textile cover (Micronics). Filtrate leaves through a central outlet. Depending on the design, the cake leaves as a slurry or as a wet or dry cake.

  • Filter press. A row of recessed plates, each lined with filter cloth, is held shut by hydraulic pressure. Slurry is pumped into the chambers between the plates. When the chambers are full, the plates are separated and the cake falls out by gravity (McLanahan).

Two differences follow from the build. The leaf filter's liquid stays inside a pressure vessel throughout; Micronics says that "can be an ideal solution for hazardous processes", and Hanke describes its leaf filters as "a closed type automatic solid-liquid separation device" (Hanke). The press opens to discharge, and Wikipedia notes that a conventional press "must be stopped to discharge the filter cake and reassemble the press, which is time-consuming" (Wikipedia).

The solids threshold nobody agrees on

Most selection guides send you to solids concentration first. Kanadevia, whose guide promotes its own filter presses, calls it "the key branching point" (Kanadevia). The problem is the number attached to it.

  • Kanadevia splits liquid filtration in two. Clarification "targets low-solids fluids (from ppm levels up to a fraction of a percent)". Dewatering "handles thick slurries (anywhere from a few percent to over 50% solids)". Its comparison table gives the filter press an optimal solids content of "Over 1% to Over 50%".

  • ChemREADY, a water treatment supplier, says "Filter presses work best when your slurry carries 50 to 60 percent solids by weight", and that "industry practice generally recommends pre-thickening any feed below 30 percent solids" (ChemREADY).

  • ErtelAlsop, another press maker, says its presses dewater solids "into filter cakes of 25-60% total concentration" (ErtelAlsop).

Read side by side, a 3 percent slurry is a press duty by Kanadevia's table and a pre-thickening problem by ChemREADY's rule. By our arithmetic, that is a factor of up to about 30 between the lowest published entry point (just over 1 percent) and the highest (30 percent before pre-thickening).

In our reading, most of the spread comes from two things, and neither is a disagreement about physics.

Whose plant the guide is written for. ChemREADY writes about wastewater and sludge, and its advice for a thin feed is to "start with a clarifier to concentrate solids before they reach the press". There the press is a last step and the goal is a smaller disposal load. Kanadevia's guide covers process liquids from clarification to dewatering, as well as sludge and mining, and in our reading that broader scope is why its press range starts lower. A guide's threshold describes the plants its author sells into.

Which number is quoted. ErtelAlsop's 25 to 60 percent is the concentration of the cake that comes out, not the feed that goes in. ChemREADY's 50 to 60 percent is stated for the slurry. The two ranges overlap, which is a reason to check, before using any figure, whether it describes the feed or the cake. A guide that does not say is not giving you a threshold you can use.

One more limit applies. None of these three guides compares a press with a leaf filter. Kanadevia's low-solids options are bag, cartridge and membrane filters, and ChemREADY's "clarifier" is a settler that thickens the feed for the press. What survives is the broad split, which Kanadevia states directly: low solids with the liquid as the product on one side, thick slurries with the cake as the product on the other. In our reading, near a few percent the solids figure alone does not decide.

Cake space is not the difference

It is easy to assume a press holds far more solids than a leaf filter. Per square metre of cloth, the published figures do not show that.

A press chamber is the gap between two recessed plates. ErtelAlsop lists cake thickness "from 20-50 mm", and 32 mm plates are standard. Kanadevia's test unit offers chambers of 25, 30 or 40 mm. Both plates in a chamber carry cloth, so cake builds from two faces and meets in the middle. Our arithmetic: each face can build at most half the chamber, so a full 20 to 50 mm chamber holds roughly 10 to 25 litres (dm³) of cake per m² of cloth.

For leaf filters, we worked through Hanke's tables in our horizontal vs vertical leaf filter article: about 30 dm³ of cake per m² of filter area across its horizontal range and about 22 across its vertical range, with the gap following leaf spacing.

So, per m² of cloth, the two machines hold cake in the same order of magnitude. Two cautions apply. Makers may count filter area differently, and a leaf filter running precoat or body feed spends part of that space on filter aid. Micronics advises precoating "until the filter aid is ¼” thick", about 6 mm. Neither caution changes the order of magnitude.

What does differ is what happens to the cake. McLanahan, writing about tailings and waste dewatering, says higher water removal than competing technologies "can be achieved" with a press "because the material being dewatered is captured between the recessed plates under the highest possible pump pressures", producing a "drip-free cake". Wikipedia says the same in general terms: presses "can offer very high performance, particularly when low residual liquid in the solid is desired". In a press, cake dryness is the point of the machine. In a leaf filter, it is a property of the discharge you choose.

What does separate them

Four questions do the work the solids percentage cannot do alone.

1. Which stream is the product? If you sell the filtrate (an oil, a solvent, a chemical solution) and the solids are a contaminant, the leaf filter's strengths line up with your interest: a closed vessel, a precoat that traps fines, and filtrate leaving through a central outlet. If you sell the solids, or pay by the tonne to dispose of them, the press's strength is the one you are buying. Kanadevia frames the same split as clarification for "final liquid purity" against dewatering to "capture and dry the solid cake".

2. How dry must the cake be? If a drip-free cake is a requirement, for transport, disposal or a downstream dryer, that favours the press, by its makers' own account. If the cake is a waste for a pit or a reprocessing step, a slurry or wet cake from a leaf filter may be acceptable.

3. Must the liquid stay enclosed? In our reading, hot, flammable, toxic or oxidation-sensitive liquids are where the closed vessel earns its place. Micronics names hazardous processes directly. A press is closed while it filters, but in our reading it is opened to the room at every discharge, along with whatever liquid the cake still holds.

4. How must the cake leave? Our engineer's rule for leaf filters: wet cake discharge suits a horizontal leaf filter, and vertical leaf filters are designed for dry cake and slurry discharge. Micronics notes the same practical point: a liquid cake drains from a valve, while "dry cakes require a much larger opening", sometimes with the whole vessel sliding back. A press is built to drop a cake. If your process needs the solids as a slurry, for re-pulping or pumping on, that is not what a press is built for.

Edible oil: where both names turn up

Edible oil shows why the label is not enough. Leaf filters are well documented in the duty. The AOCS Lipid Library article on bleaching lists "processing filters (horizontal and vertical leaf filters)" and polishing filters among the filters used (AOCS). Micronics lists edible oil processing among leaf filter applications, and US 5,628,916 describes edible oil flowing through precoated leaves, where "the particles of nickel catalyst and bleaching clay are trapped in the precoat layer" (US 5,628,916).

The same AOCS article then describes contact time as running "from the slurry tank through the filter press", speaks of "oil coming out of the bleaching filter", and gives the optimum as the moisture of oil "leaving the filter press" approaching 0.05 weight percent. In our reading, "filter press" is used there for the bleaching filter in general, after the article has named leaf filters as the processing filters. If a document or a colleague says "filter press", ask which machine is meant before comparing anything.

For the rest of the edible oil duty, including what the cake holds when it leaves, see our article on bleaching earth filtration. Our leaf filters have been used for bleaching earth filtration in edible oil refineries in India and abroad.

How to choose, in order

  1. Name the product stream. Filtrate, cake, or both.

  2. Measure feed solids, and say what basis they are on. Weight percent of the feed, not of the cake. Compare it with a guide only when you know which stream that guide's figure describes.

  3. State the cake requirement. Dry and drip-free, wet, or slurry. A dry cake requirement favours a press; a slurry requirement points away from it.

  4. List the hazards of the liquid. Temperature, flammability, toxicity, oxidation. Each one strengthens the case for a closed vessel.

  5. Check the operating pattern. Both machines are batch machines. Ask each supplier what the discharge costs in time and labour on your duty.

  6. Test the real slurry. Kanadevia says comparison charts "show only general industry trends" and recommends filtration testing once the candidates are narrowed. McLanahan says each site's material "should be tested prior to sizing". We agree: for an application new to us, we offer a trial filtration test before an order.

Where both machines are plausible on your figures, the test result should decide, not the guide.

What we build

We build horizontal and vertical leaf filters, and we build filter presses. About 1,000 units are installed worldwide across 460+ installations, in all applications, and most of those units are leaf filters. The range we build is 1.5 to 250 m². Filter media are selected to suit the application. A discharge cycle typically costs zero to one hour of downtime, depending on the process conditions. The choice between horizontal and vertical, or between a leaf filter and a filter press, is made on your process data.

Send us your duty

The most useful enquiry tells us what the product stream is, the liquid and its temperature, the feed solids and their basis, how dry the cake must be, and any hazard the liquid carries. We will tell you whether a horizontal leaf filter, a vertical leaf filter or a filter press fits your duty. For the feed mode, see precoat or body feed. Contact our engineers.

CTA BG

Have a filtration duty you want checked?

CTA BG

Have a filtration duty you want checked?

CTA BG

Have a filtration duty you want checked?